Skip to content
Comparison

Recruitment Agency or Hire Directly?

Hiring directly is usually cheaper on paper and sometimes cheaper in practice. The difference is decided by the size of the candidate pool and the cost of the gap, not by the fee.

17 November 2026 · 7 min read

The short version

Hire directly when the role is common in your area, your name already attracts applicants in that trade, and you have the time and someone to screen. Use a specialist agency when the pool is small and mostly not looking (quarry managers, shotfirers, controls engineers, HV-authorised staff), when the vacancy is costing output now, or when a mis-hire would be expensive. Direct hiring costs advertising and your team’s time; ARG’s permanent fee is 15% to 22% of first-year base salary, payable only on the start date, with a 12-week staggered rebate guarantee. Where the gap is urgent, contract cover is a third option that can run alongside either.

How do the two compare?

Hiring directlySpecialist agency
Cost you can seeAdvertising, and any assessment toolsA fee on the start date: 15% to 22% of first-year base salary at ARG
Cost you cannot seeYour team’s time screening and chasing, and every week the post stays emptyTime writing a proper brief and turning feedback round quickly
Who you reachPeople actively looking who see your advertPeople who are employed and not looking, as well as those who are
Time to a shortlistSet by your response rate and your team’s availability5 to 10 working days for a pre-screened shortlist of three to five at ARG
ScreeningDone by youDone before you see anyone, with a written summary per candidate
If the hire fails earlyStart again from the advertA staggered rebate guarantee over 12 weeks, at ARG
What you learn about the marketWhat your own advert attractsPay and availability across many live briefs
ConfidentialityThe advert is publicThe search can run without naming you

Which roles suit each route, sector by sector?

The pattern is the same in every sector: the more a role depends on a ticket, an authorisation or site-specific competence, the smaller and less active its pool, and the more an agency earns its fee. This is how it usually falls.

SectorOften fine to hire directlyUsually worth a specialist
Aggregates and building materialsLabourers and trainee operatives where you are a known local employerQuarry managers, shotfirers, fixed and heavy plant fitters, PLC engineers
ManufacturingProduction operatives in a strong local labour marketMaintenance and multi-skilled engineers, production and operations managers
Automation and controlsApprentices and graduate engineers through your own schemesPLC, SCADA, robotics and controls engineers, who are almost all employed
Industrial engineeringApprentices and traineesShift maintenance, reliability and electrical engineers on continuous-process sites
Civil engineeringGraduate engineers through graduate schemesSite agents, temporary works coordinators, quantity surveyors and planners
Renewable engineeringEntry-level technicians through training partnershipsHV-authorised engineers, offshore technicians and commissioning engineers

What does hiring directly really cost?

The fee is the only cost of an agency hire that arrives as an invoice, which is why it dominates the comparison. A direct hire has costs too; they are just spread across a calendar and a payroll, so they are easy to leave out. Before choosing, put a rough figure against each of these.

  • Advertising: job boards, social posts, and any paid promotion of the advert.
  • Screening: the hours someone in your team spends reading CVs and making first calls, and what else they would have done with them.
  • Interviewing: the hiring manager’s time, usually the most expensive hours in the process.
  • The empty post: lost output, overtime for the people covering, and any contract cover bought in, for every week it stays open.
  • A mis-hire: the cost of starting again, plus whatever went wrong while the wrong person was in the role.

If those add up to less than the fee, hire directly. On a scarce role on a production site, the empty post usually decides it on its own.

How to decide, step by step

  1. 1

    Size the pool

    Ask how many people within commuting distance can actually do this job, and how many of them are looking. A small, employed pool points to a specialist.

  2. 2

    Price the gap

    Put a weekly figure on the empty post in output, overtime and cover. That number, not the fee, is the real comparison.

  3. 3

    Choose the engagement

    Permanent, contract, or both in parallel. If the post is already empty and the work cannot wait, contract cover can start while the permanent search runs.

  4. 4

    If you use an agency, check it is a specialist

    Ask what it has filled in this role in the last year, what it says the role pays, and how it screens. A generalist reposting your advert adds cost and nothing else.

  5. 5

    Agree the terms first

    Fee, when it is due, the guarantee, and how candidates who reach you by two routes are treated, in writing before the search begins.

Questions

Is it cheaper to hire directly than to use a recruitment agency?

On the invoice, yes: a direct hire avoids the agency fee. In total, it depends on two costs that do not appear on an invoice. One is your own team’s time writing the advert, screening, chasing and interviewing. The other is the cost of the vacancy itself for every week it stays open, which on a production site is lost output, overtime and bought-in cover. For a common role in a strong local labour market, direct hiring usually wins. For a scarce role where the right people are employed and not looking, the vacancy often costs more than the fee.

How much does a recruitment agency charge in the UK?

Contingency agencies commonly charge a percentage of first-year base salary for a permanent hire, typically in the 15% to 20% range, with retained search for senior roles higher. ARG’s indicative permanent fee is 15% to 22% depending on seniority, sector and search complexity, confirmed in writing before the search starts, payable on the candidate’s first day and not on offer, and backed by a 12-week staggered rebate guarantee. Contract placements are charged as a margin on the pay rate instead.

Can we advertise directly and use an agency at the same time?

Yes, and many employers do. Agree up front how a candidate who reaches you by both routes is treated: who introduced them first, and how that is recorded. ARG’s terms set out that a candidate it introduces remains its introduction for 12 months, which is standard and worth knowing before you run both.

When is a recruitment agency the wrong choice?

When you already have a strong direct pipeline for the role, when the hiring is high-volume and entry-level and your own brand fills it, or when the agency is simply reposting your advert to the same job boards you could use yourself. A specialist earns its fee by reaching people your advert will not, and by screening against a competence gate you agree up front. If neither of those is happening, hire directly.

Where to go next

A nav-free markdown version of this guide, for reading and citation, is at https://www.andrews-recruitment.com/insights/recruitment-agency-vs-hiring-directly.md.

Not hiring this week?

We will email you when the salary guides for your sectors are updated, and when there is something in the market worth knowing. No volume.

Who are you?

Salary guide updates and market intelligence for the sectors you pick.

Sectors (leave blank for all)

I agree that Andrews Recruitment Group may email me about the sectors I have selected. I can unsubscribe at any time using the link in any email.

Got a live vacancy?

Brief us and you get a pre-screened shortlist of three to five within 5 to 10 working days, each with a written summary. Urgent contract cover is shortlisted inside 24 to 72 hours.